Methodology

High-Impact Questions (100 points each)

Criteria Points
Percentage of animal-based food purchases (2023-2024) 0-20% animal-based: 100 points
21-40% animal-based: 75 points
41-60% animal-based: 50 points
61-80% animal-based: 25 points
81-100% animal-based (or unreported): 0 points
Formal & Informal commitments (e.g., HSUS Pledge, Cool Food Pledge) Signed multiple commitments: 100 points
Signed one individual school commitment: 75 points
Working with a plant-based transition provider (e.g., Sodexo, Aramark): 50 points
Has at least one informal commitment: 25 points
Vegan main meals offered per average dinner day 3+ Vegan Main Meal Options: 100 points
2-3 Vegan Main Meal Options: 75 points
1-2 Vegan Main Meal Options: 50 points
0.5-1 Vegan Main Meal Options: 25 points
0-0.5 Vegan Main Meal Options: 0 points

Medium-Impact Questions (50 points each)

Criteria Points
Plant-based options at breakfast >4 options: 50 points
3-4 options: 40 points
2-3 options: 20 points
1-2 options: 10 points
0-1 options: 0 points
Default Veg program or pilot Currently implemented: 50 points
Piloted in the past: 25 points
Never implemented: 0 points
Plant-based culinary training Recent training (last 5 years): 50 points
Past training (more than 5 years ago): 25 points
No training: 0 points
Dedicated sustainable eating page/program Yes: 50 points
No: 0 points
Recent Changes to Food Offerings signaling a shift towards more plant-based menu Yes, major change: 50 points
Yes, minor change: 25 points
No/unreported: 0 points
Student satisfaction with plant-based options Positive survey data: 50 points
Mixed/negative survey data: 20 points
No data: 0 points

Low-Impact Questions (20 points each)

Criteria Points
Plant-based dessert options Regularly provided: 20 points
Occasionally provided: 10 points
Never provided: 0 points
Plant-based protein sources at salad bar 4+ options: 20 points
2-3 options: 15 points
1 option: 10 points
0 options: 0 points
Meatless Monday or similar program Institutional-level implementation: 50 points
Specific school/dining hall implementation: 25 points
No program: 0 points
Advertising/promotional materials for plant-based foods Yes: 20 points
No: 0 points
Sustainability Guidebook for Dining Services Yes: 20 points
No: 0 points
Labeling of plant-based foods Clear and consistent labeling without "vegan": 20 points
Inconsistent or unclear labeling, or with "vegan": 10 points
No labeling: 0 points
Naming of plant-based foods Creative/descriptive names: 20 points
Generic names (e.g., "vegan stew"): 10 points
No specific naming: 0 points

Calculate Total Scores

For each university, calculate the total score by summing the points from all categories. Example:

University A:

High-Impact: 300 points

Medium-Impact: 200 points

Low-Impact: 80 points

Total: 580 points

University B:

High-Impact: 200 points

Medium-Impact: 150 points

Low-Impact: 60 points

Total: 410 points

Maximum Points: 740